Serving Clients Full Circle

Writings by Randall

Donor Intent: The Money Was Theirs First

An interesting debate is developing in philanthropy, and I find myself firmly on the side of the donor.  In an October 13, 2026, article in The Chronicle of Philanthropy, Ben Gose examines legislation designed to strengthen donors’ legal standing when charitable organizations fail to honor restrictions on endowed gifts. His article, “New Legislation Would Strengthen Donor Standing in Gift Disputes. Does It Go Too Far?,” raises questions about donor intent, organizational flexibility, and accountability.

My perspective starts with a fundamental principle: The money originally belonged to the donor. It did not belong to the nonprofit.

When someone voluntarily transfers personal wealth to a charitable organization with specific expectations and restrictions, that organization accepts a responsibility to honor those commitments. The gift may legally become the nonprofit’s property, but that does not eliminate the obligations accompanying it.

I have heard the argument that donor restrictions can complicate organizational decision making, particularly when circumstances change. That is a legitimate concern. But I would suggest the problem frequently begins long before circumstances change.

It begins when the gift is negotiated.

Too often, organizations are so focused on securing a significant contribution that they fail to have sufficiently detailed conversations about the donor’s intentions and the organization’s future needs.

What specifically does the donor want to accomplish? What restrictions are absolute? Under what circumstances could funds be redirected? Who makes that determination? Should the donor or family be consulted? What happens if the original charitable purpose becomes impractical?

These conversations should occur before the gift agreement is signed.  We also need better gift agreements. Agreements should clearly define restrictions while establishing mutually acceptable provisions for changing circumstances. A donor might authorize alternative uses after a specified period, when particular conditions occur, or through a mutually agreed process.

I would even encourage discussing whether a portion of the gift, perhaps 10%, could support operational needs associated with fulfilling the donor’s charitable objectives. That flexibility should be negotiated openly and accepted by the donor, rather than assumed later by the organization.

These discussions may make the gift process more complicated. They may require additional meetings, legal review, and some uncomfortable conversations. Good! Those discussions are considerably less expensive than litigation, damaged relationships, or reputational harm years later.

Nonprofits have legitimate operational challenges. They must evolve as circumstances change. But those realities do not give organizations unrestricted authority to reinterpret donor commitments.

I support strengthening donors’ ability to enforce their agreements. Such protections reinforce the confidence necessary for significant philanthropy.  Ultimately, much of this debate could be avoided through more thoughtful work at the beginning of the relationship.  A few additional conversations, a carefully constructed agreement, and an honest discussion about future flexibility can prevent years of disagreement.

Honor the donor’s intent. It was their money, and the organization accepted the gift with conditions.

That commitment should mean something.