Serving Clients Full Circle

podcast

Podcasts

Listen to the weekly podcast “Around with Randall” as he discusses, in just a few minutes, a topic surrounding non-profit philanthropy. Included each week are tactical suggestions listeners can use to immediately make their non-profit, and their job activities, more effective.

Find “Around with Randall” on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.

Email Randall with a show topic: podcast@hallettphilanthropy.com

Email Randall with a thought regarding a specific show: reeks@hallettphilanthropy.com

Listen on Apple Podcasts
 
 
 
Filter

Episode 306: What is the Real Purpose of a Nonprofit? Finding Discomfort in the Right Answer

Episode 306: What is the Real Purpose of a Nonprofit? Finding Discomfort in the Right Answer
Randall Hallett

What is the true purpose of a nonprofit and why do budgets, AI, and generational change make the answer urgent now? Take a look at six practical steps, from measuring impact instead of activity to hiring leaders who challenge convention and learn how comfort can quietly keep an organization from the very difference it exists to make. It is a candid invitation to lean into discomfort and imagine what you would build if you started from scratch tomorrow.

I’m honored that you would take a few minutes of your day for this, or any edition of A round with Randall. I want to start with just a very basic premise. One of the things that I love about my role is a consultant in working with clients. I'm privileged to help them go where they want to go.

Is the sense that part of my job is to make the nonprofit, its leaders, its board, often gift officers, whomever I'm working with feel a little bit uncomfortable. And that's by design. It's not meant for power. I really don't care. It's not meant for prestige. I know one ever mentions my name again other than my wife and kids.

I'm probably okay with that. But to accomplish something, we have to go through a sense of discomfort, because if everything remains comfortable, we don't change. And that's the part of the role that I think I love the most. It's not to make them feel bad. It's to make them see the possibilities and to really answer some basic questions around, are they doing the things they should to maximize what they're trying to accomplish?

All of this is to say, is that I want to premise today's entire conversation, the thought process of my 21st century classroom, around a central question, and this may make you feel uncomfortable. What is the true nature? What is the true purpose of a nonprofit? And it's not a trick question. It's one that we probably should ask more often by the end of this.

I'm hoping that it will frame a thought process that you can take into boardrooms, into executive rooms and a team meetings, into the decision making processes that we all have to make about budgets and allocation and strategy, about who we hire and who we don't, how we grow, how we do it, is that we do what we do.

All based on just this simple concept. Is the purpose of our nonprofit known? What is that purpose and can we articulate it?

The real question that comes from that broader one is, will this so try to make this a little more tactical, and we'll kind of jump into the bigger picture. Will this whatever this is, this decision, this, this, this need, this particular direction, really allow us to make a greater difference in the existence of the people that we serve?

And that's what the real answer to the question is, isn't it? The true nature and value of the nonprofits based upon your mission is service. Are you making an impact? Are you creating a bigger impact by the changes and things that you do? And as we tend to do, what kind of start at the top and kind of work our way down the big picture, why is this question really important right now?

Why am I bringing it up? Well, we're having a lot of discussions around budgets and around AI and around who we select as board members and how we choose to add strategy or to change the direction or maximize what we're trying to accomplish. And what I'm finding more and more often, and I'm actually using this question in the conversations I'm having with some nonprofits, is that these financial pressures, this new technology, artificial intelligence, this generational change in leadership that we're beginning to see where younger leaders are coming into this with their own experiences.

But the question still stands. And what I would call entrenched practices, we keep doing the same things over and over because that's the way we've always done it. If you think that your nonprofit, either as a board member for you, for CEO, a gift officer, operational infrastructure, whomever exists to help people to make the mission that we believe in, that the organization has created its direction towards, to make a difference, to solve or to mitigate problems and help improve the lives of the people in the community.

Well, then everything from that might change a lot of decisions. And you may be saying, I'm still not tracking all of this, so let's start going from the big picture and start moving down towards why this is a problem. What am I seeing?

I'm seeing things in nonprofits when I work with them, and I may be hired from a scope of work to do. Grateful patient or capital campaign feasibility, your counsel or plan giving or various other things. But I'm seeing things like protection positions or protection of positions and the organization that decisions are not being reached about how we make a bigger impact, but how do we protect who we are today and what we've been in the past, or maybe a position or someone say, well, they're really good employee.

We sometimes see this when we have our board selections that we picked people that were most comfortable with that we know. And maybe if it's prestige or, you know, this is an honor, we're not picking people that are actually going to move the needle or challenge the status quo, but fit in because that makes us feel good. We owe them something.

It it seems a natural fit. We hire CEOs and other leaders based upon a sense of comfort. Do they fit in? Do we really want to change? If you go back about 5 or 7 episodes, I talk about that. That strategy comes from this sense of, hey, we're need to change what we're doing here. That how we look at our strategic planning.

Are we being timid in its planning? Are we really putting all the options out there, even if that makes us different in certain ways?

And are we measuring the right successes? If what you're measuring is a bottom line but not impact, are you really valuing the nonprofits goal of making a difference in the community? It's maximization level.

Now, this requires some balance because there is importance in history. There is importance in quality. There is importance in people and employees, board members, volunteers. Others deserve respect, fair compensation. The organization should embody the idea of reasonableness and responsible integration and impact into the community. If we build the nonprofits from scratch, if we started over, would we design them?

Would we build them exactly the way they are today, with the same programmatic approaches, with the same way in which we go out and we try to engage donors for the things that we want, rather than things the community needs? Would we redesign the mousetrap? And what I'm finding is, is this to the idea of what the real question is, what's the real purpose of the nonprofit that's impacting the community is causing us some challenges.

Which brings us to our tactical, in this case, six practical steps that you can use, think about, utilize to recenter the question. Actually, the answer to the question around impact. And this was where there may be some discomfort, because if we truly do this, our organizations shouldn't say static because the world isn't static. In fact, some might argue I would be amongst them, that as we go, everything gets old faster.

Not exponentially, but a little bit. If we don't change and adjust to those times, we're stuck in the past. So let's kind of jump into these six tactical things and I'll kind of break them out. The first is, is that is your board. Is your organization truly measuring outcome and impact? So when I sit in board meetings, I see a lot of balance sheets and income statements.

I hear a lot of cash flow statements too. By the way, I'm not opposed to those. Those need to be looked at and valued in their in their proper place. I hear a lot about CEOs reports, but what I failed here, either departmental or organizationally, it's what's our real impact. Have we got measurements that can truly show impact?

If you are a housing nonprofit, how many people are being put into houses, apartments, build whatever dwellings? How many days were they not on the street?

If you have a great balance sheet, a great income statement, cash flow is great. But the answer to that question is from a, let's say, housing and security perspective. Zero. I don't care how good your balance sheet is, you're not doing what you should be doing. If that was the purpose and the mission of the nonprofit.

Are we actually measuring how busy we are, or are we measuring the difference that we're making? Let me give you an example of something I read recently that I was fascinated by. I thought this was really great, and that's why I kind of did the, the, the idea of housing. I want to give credit to habitat for humanity.

Recent article talking about that habitat for humanity. A lot of the I'll call chapters. I'm not sure that's what they call them, but the local entities underneath a corporate umbrella of kind of a federated model across the United States and around the world because of interest rates going up. And part of their program is they build the house and they want to financially position the, the family to, to own the house for a long period of time, then put them in financial distress.

They're increasing and establishing loans and the way to build with credit unions and banks and opportunity to fund people who are actually looking to come in and do or receive these kind of houses, these habitat for humanity homes. So they're moving through the conversation of, hey, we just build them to yeah, we build them. But we got to find people that can get in there and be able to afford them.

That's meaningful purpose. Evaluation of the purpose of the nonprofit. It's just not to build them and say, oh, great, we're done and walk away. It's no, we want good people in there who can afford it. What do we have to do to find other aspects of owning a home that we can support?

That's a not differentiator from a mission outcome perspective, but it is a differentiator from a mission execution perspective. The mission hasn't changed, but how they need to execute it does. And that goes back to are we measuring the right things? And in some ways, can we evaluate what's holding us back and what we can do to increase that impact?

Are we measuring how busy we are? How many houses we build, or are we measuring what difference we're making? How many people are in those houses? You can apply this to food. You can play this to health care, education. There's so many social service. This is a real challenge because if we ask the question correctly, we may not like the answer, but at least it frames the direction for us to think about how we can solve that challenge.

Number two, tactically, this one's tough.

Is the use of artificial intelligence to expand or to grow capacity. And what this really comes down to is people, particularly in the nonprofit philanthropy fundraising space, I've run into a couple situations literally in the last couple of months, where as AI continues to become more integral into what's possible, particularly on the stewardship side, that there's been some commentary around, well, we can't do that because people would lose their jobs.

We wouldn't. And I'm for that. I mean, I don't want anyone to lose their job. I've been in that situation sucks. But here's the real question. Are we maximizing the use of technology AI in this particular case?

To impact and deploy talent and to serve people best that we're responsible for? Or are we holding back on this because we want to protect every existing job and is going to have an effect for profit? Nonprofit doesn't make a difference on employment. It's to get used to it. But that doesn't mean we should remove it. We need to do two things, and one, we need to embrace it because it makes the impact bigger, potentially if you use correctly.

And number two, we need to help people realize maybe in areas of our not just the nonprofit workforce, but the workforce in general, that there may be some jobs that they need to, to move from, be retrained on, be find new opportunities, grow. So the old adage, but, you know, when the automobile came in, there were some resistance to it because, well, what about people making, you know, carriages and taking care of horses and making buggy whips?

And the answer is they're not going to have a job here at some point. But the ones that figured that out sooner found other things that they could do. Talents that fit into different opportunities. So using technology to maximize opportunity to serve the mission, to make better impact. Number three is recruiting board members who can make a real contribution.

And I'm not talking about money. I'm all for money. I hope every board member is writing checks and supporting the organizations that they are strategically responsible for and fiduciary responsible for. But all too often, I see it often what Bobby's really good or Cindy's really great and we like. But are they going to challenge the status quo? When I come on to a board and I'm not asked as much anymore because I am the I think the I was this way before we got into the rapid movement of technology.

I'm a pain in the backside. I'm asking questions, what are we doing? Why are we doing that? I don't care if it's been done 100 years. Is that the right thing to do? Is that efficient? Is that effective? Why are we doing it that way? Is there a better way to do it? There are some boards that do not like that.

So now before I ever get involved with a nonprofit, I say, do you really want me? Because here's what I'm going to ask if you really want that. I'm glad to be that catalyst for change. But if you don't want that, I don't want to run into the brick wall. I got more important things to do.

Beyond a title. What can a board member contribute to the board in its mission? If they can write a $5 million check. That's great. But not everybody can do that. What other things can they do? Are you using some type of board matrix to look not at title, but the skills we're looking for and the connections that they have?

And are we really looking at people who might challenge who we are and what we do to be better?

Number four, in that same vein, are we hiring CEOs who will challenge can convention?

I remember when I first came on the road, McDonald House board here in Omaha, we had a leadership change, which I wasn't that much of a part of. It happened almost in my first board meeting that the board decided to make that adjustment. And I was pretty vocal about some concerns about process. I wasn't able to evaluate the personal decision because I wasn't there.

The process wasn't very good. And as they say, when you open your mouth, you end up with responsibility. I got to chair as an immediate board member. The selection process for the new executive director, and I really pushed them to hire someone who was incredibly young, dynamic and thought way outside the box who's going to challenge everything we were and what we would believe in.

And it got a lot of pushback. But I sometimes can be a force of nature, and that person has changed. The Ronald McDonald houses here in Omaha in ways that I don't think anybody could have ever contemplated. Certainly I couldn't, because I couldn't foresee all the knowledge and expertise she would gather. She went along to see the things that she would be able to offer to the board of, say, strategically, we could do different things, different ways to make this more meaningful.

But the point was, we didn't hire for convention or ease. We hired. I hope hiring someone that could preserve the organization's mission, but its impact in the community. I'm incredibly proud of that. I deserve no credit for it, for what they've accomplished. This person does, and the boards that have come after me. But I was really involved with saying, let's quit being safe.

Let's be strategic. Which brings me to number five. Your strategy, your strategic plans. Are they ambitious? I'm working with a client who is going through a strategic planning process. And this is what I've been pushing them on. And what's come out has been fascinating because all of a sudden they're willing to say, maybe we need to look at what we do completely differently.

That would still serve the mission, but look and act and be programmatically look different. And the answer is heck yes. Are you projecting incremental revenue and or program growth, or are you looking at. Meaning investment and possible change based on evidence, finances, risk, discipline to really build out something that can make a difference?

Are we looking to double our impact in the next five years? Are we looking just for 2% growth? Maybe that's a question you can ask. Compare the modest strategy implementation with something that might be transformational that could make a world of difference. The last is particularly when from the perspective of kind of internal review, is are you assessing or reassessing me and spending?

When I arrived at the University of Arizona medical center, we had ten events. I killed nine in the first year. I was brought in to be a catalyst change and so long standing activities I would look at and go, yeah, we're getting rid of that. Well, you can't do that. Yeah I can. And what happened was we raised a heck of a lot more money because we're spending so much time running events, and that wasn't generating revenue.

Are you conducting what I think of as an impact review of the different programs? Do you need to be everything for everybody? I would argue higher ed is coming into this in massive ways that universities cannot be everything to everybody. They're going to have to choose. We do these six, eight, ten, 15, whatever things really well. And if you want to do that, you got to go somewhere else because we just can't financially make this all work.

The impact isn't great enough. I think higher education colleges, universities are going to have massive conversations about this, and the ones that don't are going to go under particular private schools, smaller private schools. You can't be everything to everybody. What is it we are and what is it? We're not. And what can we do? I would argue health care is kind of in that same boat, larger hospitals trying to do everything.

It's like. Do we need to. Could we be more strategic? Maybe the question to ask is, if a program did not exist today, would we actually start it? Would we want it just because we've done it? The point is, is that these six tactical things. So, measuring the right outcomes from a mission perspective at the highest levels, utilizing technology and not protecting jobs, but maximizing the impact that we can have.

Recruiting board members that can change the way we look at things and make connections to community we never dreamed were possible. Hiring leaders that might not come in with, hey, I want to keep things status quo. There's they're going to challenge conventional convention, not change the mission, but change the way or possibly look at ways of doing it better.

Making strong, strategic, ambitious plans for who we can be and what we can do and reassess our kind of programing and spending to see. Look, if we didn't already have this, would we actually do it? These are things that are really going to drive nonprofits in a positive way for better outcomes, for better impact. If the purpose of the nonprofit is simply to just exist.

I would argue that you won't very long, but if it's to make a meaningful difference, the responsibility is that the differences that the future might bring us are so significant that we have to be reasonably uncomfortable, that we can do things better and lean into that discomfort to actually try. So at your next board meeting, leadership meeting, whatever it is, ask.

If we can find ways of increasing positive impact. And we agree what that is through our guiding principles, through our mission. What will we do differently tomorrow if we started from scratch tomorrow? What would we design to meet the mission that we believe it?

It's hard. This is not easy. People don't like discomfort. I don't like it. But what I know is, is it moves the needle. And that's what we're looking for. So do this at the departmental level. Do this in teams. Do this in leadership. Do this in executive groups. Do this at the board. Do this with alumni associations. Do this.

The foundation boards challenge the status quo and be willing to put forth the premise that the purpose of the nonprofit isn't jobs, is in existence, isn't individuals. It's a people in the community who need this in a meaningful way. And that may allow you to see things that you never dreamed were even possible. Don't forget to check out the blogs at Halloween three two per week.

I'm honored people read them. I'm always stunned. I was at a conference and several people that I don't even know, came up and said. “I read them every week.” 90-second reads about 500 600 words about the things I see that don't reach a podcast level. Personal insights, things that you might be able to take something from to make your world a little bit better, hopefully, or maybe just more interesting.

Get an RSS feed. That's hallettphilanthropy.com backslash blogs. And if you'd like to reach out to me, it's a podcast@philanthropy.com.

If you're willing to be a little uncomfortable to steal a little bit from the top here at the end, you will be able to do more often the thing that I believe in the most, which is that old Gaelic saying I use all the time. Some people make things happen, some people watch things happen. Then there are those who wondered what happened.

We should desire to be people and work in organizations who make things happen, which becomes devalued over time. If we don't change, we don't adjust. If we don't embrace what's possible, if we don't measure what's most important in, that's that impact. How do we make the world a better place for the things and the people and the places in our community that are wondering what happened?

That's the beauty of the nonprofit space, the philanthropic world. If you lean into that and think about yourself because you are as someone who make things happen, you can affect those who are wondering what happened. That's pretty cool way to spend every day. I can't imagine going to bed every night and putting my head on a pillow. If I didn't have the opportunity to indirectly do that on a daily basis.

I hope you sense and feel the same. I'll look forward to seeing the next time right back here on the next edition of Around with Randall. And don't forget. Make it a great day.